Where to Eat in New Buffalo

Welcome to the definitive, alphabetical directory of every dining option in New Buffalo, Michigan. From hidden local gems and waterfront dining to casual beachside grills and convenient national favorites, our community offers choices for every taste, schedule, and budget.

Whether you are seeking upscale fine dining, craft beer on an outdoor patio, or a familiar quick-service bite on your way through town, you will find it in our comprehensive list below. Explore local menus, dining styles, and contact details for every eatery across the New Buffalo footprint.

Fine Dining & Waterfront

— For date nights, elevated menus, and upscale dining.

• Bentwood Tavern
  – American, Contemporary Cuisine
  – Vegetarian friendly
  – Gluten free options
  – Accepts Credit Cards
  – Breakfast, Lunch, Dinner

  Marina Grand Resort
  600 W. Water St.
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  
  

• Copper Rock Steakhouse
  – Steakhouse, Seafood Cuisine
  – Dinner Only
  – Vegetarian friendly
  – Gluten free options

  Four Winds Casino Resort
  11113 Wilson Rd
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  
  

• Four Winds Casino Buffet
  – American Cuisine
  – Lunch & Dinner
  – Vegetarian friendly

  Four Winds Casino Resort
  11111 Wilson Rd.
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  
  

• PostBoy
  – American Cuisine
  – Seasonal selections
  – Global Flavors
  – Outdoor Seating
  – Beer, Wine & Cocktails
  – Children’s Menu

  207 N. Whittaker St
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  

• Skip’s Restaurant & Catering
  – American, Steakhouse
  – Meal types
  – Dinner, Drinks
  – Free off-street parking
  – Full Bar
  – Wheelchair Accessible

  16710 Lakeshore Rd.
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  
  

• Terrace Room
  – Italian, Contemporary Cuisine
  – Wine Bar
  – Dinner
  – Vegetarian friendly
  – Gluten-free options

  Harbor Grand Hotel
  111 West Water Street
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  
  

• The Hummingbird Lounge
  – Bar, Pub
  – Dinner, Drinks
  – Wheel Chair Accessible
  – Outdoor Seating

  9 South Barton St.
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  

• Whittaker Woods Bar & Grill
  – classic bar and grill fare
  – Fri – Sun: 8am until Dusk
  – Indoor Seating
  – Outdoor Seating
  – Views of 18th hole

  Whittaker Woods Golf Course
  12578 Wilson Rd
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  (269) 469-3400

Craft Breweries, Pubs & Grills

— The local heart of town. Casual sit-down spots for burgers, beer, pizzas, and global eats.

• Beer Church Brewing Co.
  – Bar, Gastropub
  – Lunch, Late Night
  – Outdoor Seating
  – Wine & Beer
  – Take-out

  24 S Whittaker St
  New Buffalo, MI 49117-1820
  
  

• Casey’s Bar & Grill
  – American, Bar, Pub Cuisine
  – Gluten free options
  – Lunch, Dinner, Late Night
  – Takeout
  – Outdoor Seating

  136 N. Whittaker Street
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  
  

• El Fuego Grill & Bar
  – Latin-Inspired & Authentic Mexican
  – All-Day Dining & Robust Breakfast
  – Open 8am – 5pm daily
  – Outdoor Seating
  – Tequilas and Mezcals
  – Family/kid friendly

  18529 Harbor Country Dr.
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  

• Ghost Isle Brewery
  – American, Bar, Pub Cuisine
  – Lunch, Dinner, Drinks
  – Outdoor Seating
  – Live Music

  17684 U.S. 12
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  
  

• Kankakee Grille
  – American, Bar, Pub Cuisine
  – Lunch, Dinner, Drinks
  – Table Service

  Four Winds Casino Resort
  11111 Wilson Rd.
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  
  

• Redamak’s
  – Legendary Burger Joint
  – American, Bar Cuisine
  – Lunch, Dinner, Drinks
  – Gluten free options
  – Cash Only

  616 East Buffalo St
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  
  

• Rios Mexican Food
  – Mexican Cuisine
  – Lunch, Dinner
  – Drive-thru
  – Outdoor Seating
  – Indoor Seating
  – Takeout
  – Wheelchair Accessible

  603 E. Buffalo St.
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  
  

• Roma Pizza
  – Italian, Pizza
  – Breakfast, Dinner
  – Delivery & Take-out
  – Full Bar
  – Outdoor Seating
  – Wheelchair Accessible

  17600 Red Arrow Hwy
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  
  

• Sonny D’s Bar and Grill
  – Italian, American, Contemporary Cuisine
  – Lunch, Dinner, Brunch, Late Night
  – Credit Cards Accepted
  – Live Music
  – Parking Available
  – Serves Alcohol

  1 North Whittaker St.
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  
  

• Song Asian Cuisine
  – Chinese, Japanese, Asian, Korean Cuisine
  – Sushi
  – Lunch, Dinner
  – Vegetarian friendly
  – Vegan options
  – Indoor Seating
  – Takeout
  – Wheelchair Accessible

  301 W. Buffalo St (US-12)
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  
  

• Stray Dog Bar & Grill
  – American Cuisine
  – Lunch, Dinner
  – Vegetarian friendly
  – Vegan options
  – Gluten free options
  – Parking Available
  – Waterfront
  – Rooftop Dining

  245 North Whittaker Street
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  
  

• Villa Nova Pizzeria
  – Italian, Pizza
  – Lunch, Dinner, Drinks
  – Vegetarian friendly
  – Gluten free options
  – Outdoor Seating
  – Wheelchair Accessible

  134 W. Buffalo St.
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  
  

Cafes, Delis & Specialty Markets

— Breakfast spots, heavy sandwich boards, daytime bistros, and curated provisions.

• Angela’s Provisions
  – Italian, American, Deli, Soups
  – Breakfast, Lunch
  – Open daily 8:00am – 2:30pm

  225 N. Whitaker St
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  

• Brewsters Italian Cafe
  – Upscale daytime/evening cafe
  – Italian, American, Contemporary Cuisine
  – Lunch, Dinner, Drinks
  – Vegetarian friendly
  – Vegan options
  – Gluten-free options
  – Full Bar
  – Wheelchair Accessible
  – Credit Cards Accepted

  11 W. Merchant Street
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  
  

• David’s Delicatessen & The False Front
  – American, Cafe, Deli Cuisine
  – Breakfast, Lunch
  – Vegetarian friendly
  – Vegan options
  – Gluten-free options
  – Closed Tuesdays

  The False Front is a neighborhood bar featuring signature cocktails, local beer, fine wine & spirits and housemade snacks. Open Wednesday-Monday 6pm-midnight eastern time. Patio open seasonally.
  30 N. Whittaker St.
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  
  

• Issa Vibe Cafe
  – Third-wave coffee and brews
  – high-end drinks
  – All our flavors/syrups are made in-house
  – Grilled paninis
  – Fresh salads
  – In-house desserts
  – Open 9am-5pm

  211 E Buffalo St.
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  
  

• Jackie’s Cafe
  – American, Cafe, Fusion Cuisine
  – Breakfast, Lunch
  – Vegetarian friendly, Vegan & Gluten-free options
  – Outdoor Seating
  – Wheelchair Accessible

  801 W. Buffalo St
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  
  

• Luisa’s Cafe
  – American, Cafe, European, Swedish Cuisine
  – Breakfast, Lunch, Brunch
  – Vegetarian friendly, Vegan options
  – Takeout
  – Wheelchair Accessible

  13698 Red Arrow Hwy
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  
  

• Zoe’s Bakery
  – Tues – Sun Noon – 7pm
  – Online Ordering

  255 N. Whittaker St.
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  

Ice Cream, Bakeries & Sweets

— Post-beach treats, coffee runs, and dessert walks.

• Oinks Dutch Treat
  – An absolute must-visit landmark
  – Ice cream
  – Espresso, Cappuccino, and Latte Coffees
  – Chocolate and fudge
  – 40 flavors of Jelly Belly beans
  – Open daily 11:30am – 11:00pm

  227 W Buffalo St (across from City Hall)
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  
  

• Starbucks
  116 N. Whittaker St.
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  (269) 231-5175

Fast Food & Quick-Service

— Fast grab-and-go spots, highway stops, and late-night beach snacks.
 

• McDonalds
  18881 La Porte Rd.
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  (269) 469-1924
• Nancy’s at the Lake
  – American Cuisine
  – Ice cream
  – Shakes
  – Burgers
  – Hot Dogs

  142 N Whittaker St
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  

• New Buffalo Beach Snack Bar
  – Open Seasonally
  – 1/4 lb. Angus beef hot dogs
  – Nachos and cheese
  – Pretzels
  – Kona Ice
  – Ice Cream
  – Beach Essentials (sunscreen, pain relievers, umbrellas, and sand toys)

  @ the Public Beach
  New Buffalo, MI 49117

• The Standard Sub Shop
  – 6″, 12″ or 18″ subs
  – Boar’s Head Meats
  – Turano Baking Co. Bread
  – JR Bakery Desserts
  – Gluten-free options
  – Unique chips
  – Specialty drinks
  – Open 10am – 4pm

  19 North Whittaker St.
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  

• Subway
  18913 Harbor Country Dr
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  (269) 469-5961
• Timbers Fast Food & Deli
  Four Winds Casino Resort
  11111 Wilson Rd.
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  (866) 494-6371