Spend time in New Buffalo, Michigan, and discover why generations of families return to our lakeside shores year after year. Extending your getaway with a private vacation rental gives you the space, comfort, and flexibility to experience Harbor Country like a local.
To help you find the perfect match, our comprehensive directory features New Buffalo’s premier property management agencies below—local hospitality experts who can handle your direct bookings, guest services, and custom requests. Following our featured agencies, you will find a hand-selected catalog of individual cabins, beach cottages, and downtown condos curated in partnership with TripAdvisor to give you real-time access to the area’s best inventory. (As a travel partner, we may earn a small commission on qualifying bookings at no extra cost to you.)
Don’t wait too long to reserve your dates—the best beachfront and downtown properties book quickly for the summer season!
Featured Local Property Management Agencies
Connect directly with New Buffalo’s premier, full-service hospitality groups. Booking your stay through these local experts ensures personalized guest services, insider recommendations, and seamless reservation management for your lakeside getaway.
WAYA Vacation Home Rentals
Harbor Country & Indiana Beaches
Ron Morales
(312) 952-8361
Premium vacation rental properties – Pet-friendly homes available.
— Featured in WEST SUBURBAN LIVING Magazine
Dan Saunders
New Buffalo, MI 49117
(269) 371-2200
Offering select vacation homes in the New Buffalo / Harbor Country Michigan
10234 Community Hall Road
Union Pier, MI 49129
(269) 469-0468
Weekly rentals during peak season – June through August.
— Featured in the March 2018 issue of WEST SUBURBAN LIVING Magazine
Vacation Rentals in and around New Buffalo, Michigan
Follow the links in this section to find vacation rental properties that travelers trust – unbiased reviews by TripAdvisor®!
2 BR on the Galien River (Sleeps 6)All-season cottage that can comfortably accommodate up to 6 adults; it is just a five-minute walk to a private beach on Lake Michigan, ideal for a girls weekend or a longer family getaway.
[ Read More ]
A-Frame @ the Lake (Sleeps 12) ‘Designer Beach House’ meets ‘A-Frame Cabin’ – north woods feel right just 500 ft from Lake Michigan and a short stroll to downtown New Buffalo for shopping, dining, and ice cream!
[ Read More ]
Charmer @ Great Location (Sleeps 9)Charming family home in the heart of New Buffalo – close to restaurants, shops, and lakefront park/public beach. Spacious bedrooms, three full baths, two fireplaces, and two porches.
[ Read More ]
Creekside Cottage on 30 secluded acres of woods (Sleeps 10)The newly appointed 3 BR/2 BA cottage is located in a quiet and secluded location surrounded by nature. Pool, hot tub, hiking trails, and more.
[ Read More ]
Designer Cottage in Grand Beach (Sleeps 12)Huge secluded property in Grand Beach New Buffalo featuring a Main House (3bdr) and Guesthouse (1bdr).
[ Read More ]
Easy walk to Town (Sleeps 9)This lovely home is on a quiet, tree-lined street with everything you’ll need for a wonderful vacation getaway. Located less than a 10-minute walk to the heart of New Buffalo.
[ Read More ]
Hampton’s style Retreat (Sleeps 8)The highlight of this home is the Hampton’s style pool, with a bluestone patio, outdoor shower, and fire pit that is it’s own oasis. As a bonus, the home is across the street from the beach.
[ Read More ]
Lakefront, pool and hot tub (Sleeps 14)Mile-wide Lake Michigan views and a great open floor plan make this 4BR/3.5BA lakefront home a dream come true! Dramatic two-story great room with spectacular views of Lake Michigan.
[ Read More ]
Apple Blossom Resort. 3 Homes. 11 Bedrooms/12 Bathroom. Pool. Hot Tub. Fire-PitApple Blossom Resort is a one-of-a-kind luxury vacation rental property featuring three homes on a private 18-acre estate in SW Michigan’s Harbor Country.
[ Read More ]
Luxury Beach House (Sleeps 16)Newly built vacation home in the heart of New Buffalo – tucked away on a private drive. Two separate floors, two family rooms, two master suites, huge screened-in porch with ample seating overlooking a wooded setting.
[ Read More ]
Riverfront Rental (Sleeps 14)Log cabin on six beautiful acres of land with over 500 feet of Galien River wrapping around the property. Conveniently located — less than 10-minute drive to Four Winds Casino, area beaches, marina, restaurants, golf courses, and more.
[ Read More ]
See more vacation rental homes, condos, cottages, and villas available for rent by owner – CLICK HERE
Directory Information & Disclaimers
For Your Protection: NewBuffalo.com serves strictly as an informational directory and advertising venue connecting travelers with independent vacation rental owners, professional property management agencies, and third-party booking platforms (including TripAdvisor). We are not directly involved in any lodging transactions, reservations, or rental agreements between guests and host parties.
Consequently, we do not control, warrant, or assume liability for the availability, legal compliance, quality, safety, or accuracy of any listed property, nor can we guarantee that a host or guest will successfully complete a rental transaction. All verification of rates, amenities, and booking terms remain the sole responsibility of the renting party. As an affiliate partner, qualifying clicks on platform feeds may result in a small commission earned by this site to help support our local community guides.
Help Us Maintain Quality: To ensure the integrity of our community guide, we greatly appreciate your feedback! If you have a particularly positive or negative experience with any local property manager or rental listing found on our site, please let us know via our contact form so we can keep our directory as reliable as possible.
